The best Scottish cheeses

  • The Larder
  • 17 September 2010
The best Scottish cheeses for your board

It’s perfectly possible to fill your cheese board with artisan cheeses made in Scotland – in fact, you’ll be spoilt for choice. The Larder has teamed up with Pierre Leger of much-respected cheese retailer and wholesaler Clarks Speciality Foods to assemble a local cheese board featuring some of the country’s prime cuts.

Red Anster

The sister of the crumbly pressed cheese made by Jane Andrews of the St Andrews Farmhouse Cheese Company near Anstruther in Fife, it’s made from unpasteurised cow’s milk and is naturally flavoured with garlic and chives. The orange colour comes from annatto, a natural plant extract.

As the only naturally flavoured artisan or farmhouse cheese made in Scotland, Red Anster is out on its own. Simple Crowdie can be flavoured with herbs or peppercorns, such as the Loch Arthur Creamery’s Crannog. If you like this style of cheese but not the flavouring, original Anster has a fresh, lemony tang while the Connage Highland Dairy’s Cromal is an organic, light and crumbly cheese with clean flavours made from pasteurised cow’s milk.

Ailsa Craig

Attractively shaped and named after the landmark island in the Firth of Clyde, this is an individual, fresh, fragile goat’s cheese with a bloomy rind and a light and fluffy texture. Made by Ann Dorward in Dunlop, it’s one of the very few goat’s cheeses made in Scotland, and still only made in limited quantities.

Putting a plain goat’s or ewe’s milk cheese on a cheese board opens up another broad avenue of tastes and textures. Ann Dorward makes a number of these, including Glazert and Bonnet, both goat’s milk cheeses. Based at Millaires Farm, Sorbie, by Newton Stewart, Galloway Farm Cheeses also makes the aromatic, nutty-flavoured Cairnsmore cheese using organic, unpasteurised ewe’s milk, but only in the summer months.


Made in Dumfriesshire by Barry Graham and the inspiring Loch Arthur Creamery, part of a Camphill community offering vocational opportunities to adults with learning disabilities, Criffel is an organic, unpasteurised cow’s milk cheese with a sweet, creamy paste and a contrasting washed rind. Semi-soft in texture, it carries some strong, pungent flavours and is certainly a contender for the most impressive cheese currently being made in Scotland.

Criffel does stand out for its distinctive style but it is worth looking out for Lanark White, made seasonally from ewe’s milk by Humphrey Errington in Lanarkshire, as well as his Maisie’s Kebbuck, a slightly firmer, unpressed cow’s milk cheese with a natural rind.

Dunsyre Blue

A soft blue, mould-ripened cheese made using unpasteurised milk from Ayrshire cows by Humphrey Errington on his farm by Carnwath in Lanarkshire. When aged, the smooth, cream-coloured cheese is streaked with blue-green mould, and while it has a spicy flavour, it’s mellower and creamier than its seasonal sister cheese, Lanark Blue, made from ewe’s milk.

A number of other blue cheeses are made in Scotland. Highland Fine Cheese’s Strathdon Blue and Aberdeenshire's Devenick Dairy’s Badentoy Blue appeal to those looking for a milder, creamier blue, while Fatlips Castle Blue, made near Hawick by Jim and Annie Shanks' Standhill Cheesery, is produced in small rounds as a soft blue-veined cheese in the style of a blue camembert (cambozola).

Morangie Brie

As the name hints, this creamy, cow’s milk brie is made near Tain by Ruaraidh Stone of Highland Fine Cheeses. It can be eaten as young as six weeks though it can mature for a number of months, with larger rounds tending to develop more flavour than smaller versions. The milk is pasteurised, so it won’t ever reach the ripe tanginess of a cheese made from unpasteurised milk.

Alternatives include the organic brie, Clava, made by Connage Highland Dairy, and the Devenick Dairy brie-style Monarch. In the Borders, the Standhill Cheesery has its Roxburgh Roondie.

Cambus o’May

A recent addition to the Scottish cheese scene, this pressed cheese from the eponymous Cambus o’May creamery on Royal Deeside is made with unpasteurised milk. Using a technique called 'two-day curd', where the curds from two separate days’ milking are mixed together to achieve a distinctive marbled effect, the cheese is pale in colour but has some lovely nutty and earthy flavours.

Alternatives to this include more familiar pressed cheeses such as a classic Dunlop. Chris and Jeff Reade’s Isle of Mull Cheddar is much loved, though undoubtedly fiercer when mature. Blarliath from Highland Fine Cheeses is an increasingly popular milder alternative cheddar-style farmhouse cheese

A Connage Highland Dairy
Milton of Connage, Ardersier, Inverness, Highland, IV2 7QU
Connage Highland Dairy is a traditional, family-owned, fully organic business. A family business in the true sense of the word, Connage is owned by brothers Callum and Cameron and their wives Jill and Eileen. Callum and Jill manage the cheese side of…
B Loch Arthur Creamery and Farmshop
Beeswing, Dumfries and Galloway, DG2 8JQ
Grown out of the productive efforts of a diverse and vibrant community, Loch Arthur Creamery is a Camphill Community and social enterprise, inclusive of people with learning disabilities and committed to creating meaningful work. 75 people now live in…
C St Andrews Farmhouse Cheese Company
Falside Farm, Anstruther, Fife, KY10 2RT
Cheesemaker and farm café serving local produce and home baking with views towards the sea.
D Devenick Dairy
Bishopston Farm, Banchory-Devenick, Aberdeenshire, AB12 4RS
Devenick Dairy was born in 2006 when the Groat family decided to use their fresh milk to create their own products. They now produce a wide range of cheeses, yoghurt and cheesecake – including a cranachan flavour with raspberries and toasted oats. At…

Get 50% off your first Cheese Club delivery from Pong Cheese — cheese box subscription

Enjoy a hand-picked selection of delicious cheeses, neatly packaged and sent to you. Take 50% off your first Cheese Club order with this discount code.